| Show Date | Judge | Theme | Stewards |
| May 5 | Addison Tomanelli | Secretariat | Jacki Patenaude, Jenn Crossman |
| June 23 | Michelle Hunting | Misty of Chincoteague | Megan Perrin, Karen Chamberland |
| July 21 | Corrine Proulx | Mr. Ed | Kate Rand, Teri Smith, Catherine Galbraith |
| August 11 | Gina Lindell | Black Beauty | Jim & Lori Saltojanes, Melissa Kohler |
| September 22 | Heidi Smith | Snowman | Deb & Sarah Gada |
| October 6 | Karol Bennett | Headless Horseman | Alyssa Kinsey, Jamie Boyer, Sabrina Winthers |